REVIEW & REJIG: Hungarian mushroom soup recipe

A bowl of low-sodium Hungarian Mushroom SoupI was off sick from work today and slept most of the day away. When I awoke, I was feeling much better, but was absolutely famished. I considered calling and ordering some take-out chicken soup from Swiss Chalet until I looked up the nutritional value. For one bowl of chicken and vegetable noodle soup was over 1000mg of sodium!! No thank you!

My husband suggested that I make my own. The problem with that was that I had no chicken in the fridge! I had veggies and broth and whole wheat egg noodles (no yolk) but no chicken. Can’t have chicken soup without chicken, can we?

But by this point, I knew I wanted soup. So I went scouring around the web, looking for ideas. I knew I had about a pound of mushrooms that needed to be used up soon, so I based my searching on that ingredient. What I found was an intriguing recipe over on called Hungarian Mushroom Soup. I was surprised to find out that with the exception of the fresh parsley (I just had dried), I had all of the ingredients.

This is one of those times where I kept pretty darned close to the original recipe, but here are the adjustments I made to help with some of my own dietary needs:

  • instead of all purpose flour, I used whole wheat flour
  • instead of fresh parsley, I used 2 Tbsp of dried parsley
  • reduced sodium soy sauce replaced regular soy sauce
  • reduced sodium chicken broth/flavouring (2 cups organic reduced sodium broth + 1/6 of a pot of Knorr’s Homestyle reduced sodium chicken stock) replaced regular broth
  • only a pinch of salt was used during the mushroom sauteing process (instead of using a teaspoon at the end for seasoning) to help them release their liquid a bit quicker
  • skim milk and fat free sour cream was used in my version
  • and finally, I served the soup over 1/4 cup of cooked whole wheat no yolk egg noodles

That looks like a lot of substituting and rejigging, but it really isn’t, hence why I’m not including a recipe. Pop over to the original recipe on and check it out.

Here’s the nutritional value based on my substitutions:

Makes: 5 servings

Nutritional value per serving (w/o noodles): 183 calories, 19g carbs, 10g fat, 6g protein, 343mg sodium, 6g sugar

Nutritional value per serving (with noodles): 220 calories, 26g carbs, 11g fat, 8g protein, 347mg sodium, 6g sugar

And now for my review of this recipe:

This was truly an unexpected pleasure. The soup is flavourful, robust and hearty. I was surprised by how much flavour was in this soup, to be honest. There is a richness and deepness to its taste that is surprising, along with that sourness that I’ve tasted in Hungarian and German food before. The dill was stronger than I expected, but not unpleasantly so. This made a decent sized pot of soup and I’m looking forward to finishing it off through the week.

All told, this one is a “keeper” in my books. There aren’t too many ingredients, so it’s likely that you might have all the ingredients on hand, even when the cupboards are getting bare. It won’t break the bank, though, if you have to run out to get everything (primarily broth, onion, sour cream and mushrooms). The whole thing cooks up in one pot on the stove and takes maybe 45 minutes from start to finish, max. This makes for a really quick and easy meal to make, as soups go.

The only issue I had with this is that the recipe suggests the batch makes 6 servings. I figured that meant a cup a piece. At a cup a piece, it actually only makes about 5 one-cup servings. If you want to stretch it to 6, you’ll need to limit it to something like 3/4 cup servings and you might squeak out just barely 6 servings. But frankly, I found a 1-cup bowl to be perfect.

It’s low in calories, not bad for carbs and the sodium level is more than respectable. Even the fat could be cut back a bit if you reduced the amount of unsalted butter used to saute the onions and mushrooms in, but I think 9 grams isn’t bad at all. Pair this up with a salad or handful of sliced cucumbers & baby tomatoes and a few crackers and you’ve got yourself a really great lunch.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s